Become a member

News

News / Technical

KELLOGG’S LEGAL CHALLENGE TO HFSS CLAMPDOWN REJECTED BY HIGH COURT

Earlier in the year Kellogg’s took legal action against the governments ban on HFSS promotions. However, it was confirmed early in July that Kellogg’s legal challenge had been rejected by the High Court.

Kellogg’s argued that cereals shouldn’t be exempt from prominent in store displays and volume sales because they are usually consumed with milk, which adds to the nutritional value of a portion. They claimed that the cereals should be treated the same way as products mixed with liquid before consumption, such as custard powder and dried pasta, which are based on their nutrient profile once reconstituted according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Another issue they raised, which could have derailed the entire HFSS clampdown if successful, was it should be declared “ultra vires” or “beyond the powers” of the Food Safety Act of 1990. They argued a further act of parliament was required to give local authorities powers to fine stores for breaches of HFSS regulations.

Finally, their third point was around the controversial nutritent profiling model, used to assess whether products should be included in the clampdown. As the NPM was created in 2004 as the basis for Ofcom’s policing of advertising aimed at children, it was never properly scrutinised by parliament for the purposes of the HFSS clampdown.

All three grounds for the challenge were rejected following a High Court judicial review.

Breakfast cereals may have liquids added to them or be mixed with other products before they are eaten, but this is not necessarily the case,” said Mr Justice Linden on Kellogg’s milk argument.

“Many of them can be eaten in dry form. They do not come with instructions for preparation which say that they should be consumed with milk, although I accept that their packaging and messaging will often depict or refer to milk with the cereal and some manufacturers include information as to nutritional values in the event that they are consumed with a specified quantity of milk.

“The fact that manufacturers provide information as to nutritional values, rather than manufacturer’s instructions, is not just a reflection of the different nature of breakfast cereals; it also illustrates a practical difference in terms of the availability of an effective standardised approach.”

 

Articles over 1 year old See Technical News Archive
Member Benefits

Exclusive Partnership deals on key products and services:

  • BFFF energy deals and rates
  • Vypr member deals and introduction
  • Defib Plus deals
  • Company Shop – membership
  • Mentor – MHE training health check

Exclusive access to networking opportunities and events:

  • Meet the Buyer events (retail & foodservice)
  • Annual Business Conference with networking dinner
  • Specialist H&S and Technical Conferences
  • Special interest groups (packaging, frozen food temperatures)
  • Annual Lunch
  • Awards Night
Upcoming Events More Events
Sponsorship Packages

We offer a range of sponsorship opportunities to BFFF members across our events throughout the year, with flexible packages that can be tailored to suit your business objectives.

Contact Us
British Frozen Food Federation Members Logo
what our members say...
  • Wakefield Council

    “What an amazing piece of work and indicative of how BFFF respond to the concerns of their members and make an impact on the whole industry sector.”

    See Full Quote

  • Sysco

    “You guys really ‘Do The Right Thing’ for the good of the industry”

    See Full Quote

  • Darta

    “The BFFF awards night is becoming an “appointment not to miss” on our calendar and we again enjoyed it immensely together with lots of well-known people from our industry. The…

    See Full Quote

  • Kantar Worldpanel

    “The Business Conference was an excellent day that was very well organised and allowed so many likeminded individuals in the room to learn so much more around the Frozen industry….

    See Full Quote

  • Lakeside Food Group Ltd

    “This Not For EU labelling situation alarmed us and quickly became a major worry to our business. These are times when you really rely on some support and from previous…

    See Full Quote

  • Meadow Vale Foods Limited

    “We had a few questions with respect to the new EPR waste packaging legislative changes. I know some of my colleagues have been assisted by BFFF in the past so…

    See Full Quote

  • Newberry International Produce Ltd

    “I am writing to express my heartfelt gratitude for the outstanding event you organised. I have only worked in this sector for the past nineteen months coming from twenty-five years…

    See Full Quote

  • Place UK Ltd

    “The BFFF 2024 Conference was compelling and thought provoking, with a many relevant and interesting topics covered at great pace and some depth by excellent speakers – will certainly attend…

    See Full Quote

  • Roswel Spedition GMBH

    “Thank you and the team for rushing around so brilliantly before, during and after the conference. It was pleasure to be part of the conference.”

    See Full Quote

  • Seara

    “The event was great, in my opinion. Not only it was very well organised, but the venue and the catering were excellent too. Furthermore, the content of the presentations was…

    See Full Quote

Website Designed & Built by we are CODA